[Rt-devel] [PATCH] xhtml-ize html/Tickets/Create.html

Robert Spier rspier at pobox.com
Sun Jul 31 15:15:56 EDT 2005


Steve Peters wrote:
> While trying to figure out what I was doing wrong with my configuration,
> I ran across some old uppercase HTML.  There are also some unquoted tag
> attributes.  This would be OK had the file not said that it was xhtml.
> 
> This diff is against the 3.5.2 snapshot, but I didn't see any difference in 
> svn in this file since then.

I'm not very big on XHTML.  (Although it's Jesse's call, of course.)

A few weeks ago I did some reading up on it, and basically the *only* 
advantage to xhtml is that you can put it through an xml validator 
instead of a html validator.

One downside is that for some browsers to properly detect and render 
xhtml you need to send it as a special mime type.  application/xhtml+xml

Another is that XHTML is *not* a superset of HTML.  For various reasons 
(cough, sgml, cough), legal xhtml constructs are not legal HTML constructs.

In my world, I've decided to stick with HTML 4.01.  Uppercase tags vs 
lowercase tags?  I don't really care.

-R
(On an airplane.)



More information about the Rt-devel mailing list